really glad i chose to go and see them last night, could have been in salford watching the poor performance i watched when i got home c/o sky+!

really did not enjoy the 8 mile walk looking for my car post gig!

+1. Feeling it a bit today though.

In years to come I wonder how many of the fans that were actually at the Salford game claim to have attended this gig.

I've told so many people I was at Spike Island that now I'm starting to think I actually was.

Why pretend you was somewhere you weren't? Quite sad really

'really did not enjoy the 8 mile walk looking for my car post gig!"

There was a similarity between the gig and the game then.. Playing Frogger to get to Barton international airport car park

Anyone that didn't go because they thought it was going to be rubbish made a big mistake.

Brilliant.

I think if you were expecting it to be good, then they will share your opinion.....My son thought it was going to be ropey, got a ticket for £20, and, as he expected, reported back that it was ropey, with quite dodgy sound.....Said Reni was a good drummer, but that overall it wasn't worth the 60 odd quid ticket price.

After the disaster that was Reading 96 I was a bit worried in truth and although technically the band are not the best musicians in the world (not including John Squire who can hold his own with anybody) it didn't really matter.

Tremendous festival atmosphere and up there with some of the best gigs I have attended.

If its any help I'm pretending that I didn't go to the stone roses gig and didn't miss salfords best win of the season (or maybe second best after the come back against catalans)

That said the stone roses were absolutely fantastic despite the slightly dodgy sound system. Great atmosphere and great performance and I got to watch the mighty reds on v+ on Saturday morning

Seriously? Mani is a very good bass player and Reni is up there with the best of them as a drummer. The two of them are really tight as a rhythm section.

From what i saw of both of these , not too mention the rest of the band were very average.

The sound at first on saturday was awful and barely audible, it got better after it went dark and was then pretty entertaining. The last few songs the atmosphere was good and they played them well.

Anyone who thought this was a good concert must have very limited experience of outdoor concerts, or just love the stone roses so much that anything would be great.

Overall was poor, but the last hour was fun.

Getting away was rubbish but that is my fault for not making any arrangements....

Did they play "This Is The One"? As they didn't play it at The Part Hall the other week for some reason and its my favourite.