Whilst he ran in it supremely well, you can't help but be mystified by the video ref ignoring the 2 or 3 knock ons he did onto Roby. We are ignoring technicalities like multiple knock ons in order to reward good play?

Bizarre.

You didn't listen to Eddie & Stevo. It was cos it looked good they gave the try.....

A joke, although it was great to see Carvell go.

Proves once and for all that some of the officials simply don't know or understand the rules.

Pathetic.

I hate technicalities anyway. A knock on should only apply if it hits the floor.

Beyonce [ishould[/i be coming to my house tonight for a massage, but it's not the way things are.

with out the vid ref it would of been given straight away, not saying that is the right thing but it just would

I don't think it would, because he enquired over that incident, meaning he saw it well enough to make a judgement on. It was clearly a knock on, it bounced between the two like a pinball in real time.

But you'd throw out life's rule book if she did wouldn't you?

I'd refer it upstairs to the video wife.

Except when a Halifax player does it in the Semi-Final of the NRC

He didn't knock on. He threw it away